2024 Ultimate Long Island Guide to Spots For Christmas Eve Dinner, Santa Brunches, Holiday Catering, & Desserts!

Long Islanders, the holidays are here! Whether you’re planning a cozy Christmas Eve dinner, a festive holiday party, or simply need someone else to handle dessert this year, our Ultimate Holiday Dining & Catering Guide has got you covered. From elegant dinners and perfect party venues to top-tier catering and indulgent holiday treats, you’ll find everything you need to make this season stress-free and delicious.

Christmas Eve Dinner

Bayberry

Celebrate Christmas Eve in style at Bayberry with their exquisite holiday specials, available from 4 to 8 PM. Indulge in a tender Filet Mignon with garlic confit potato purée and butter poached asparagus or savor the melt-in-your-mouth Braised Short Rib with parsnip purée and winter vegetables. For a luxurious twist, enjoy our Surf N’ Turf featuring both Filet Mignon and Maine Lobster Tail, complete with a rich caramelized shallot demi-glace. Treat yourself to an unforgettable evening of festive flavors and elevated cocktails. Call to Reserve! (631) 210-0011.

Where: 501 Main Street, Islip, www.bayberryislip.com.

View 

Join the View for a festive season of holiday cheer, delicious cuisine, and unforgettable memories. Start the celebrations with our Brunch with Santa on Sunday, December 22nd, with seatings available from 11:00 AM to 12:30 PM. Then, gather with loved ones for a special Christmas Eve Dinner on Tuesday, December 24th, featuring holiday-inspired specials crafted just for the occasion, served from 4:00 PM to 8:00 PM. Make this holiday season magical at View—reservations are required. Call For Reservations! (631) 589-2694.

Where: 3 Consuelo Place, Oakdale, www.viewoakdale.com.

Nomiya Station

Celebrate the holidays with a sushi experience like no other at Nomiya Station. For Christmas Eve, enjoy their special menu featuring creative rolls in an elegant setting. Hosting a party? Nomiya Station offers catering platters that are as beautiful as they are delicious. Don’t forget their exclusive Suntory Highball Whiskey cocktail and much more at their full bar. Don’t miss out! Celebrate the holidays in style at Nomiya! Make reservations now by clicking here.

Where: 630 Old Country Road, Garden City (Roosevelt Field Mall), www.nomiyastation.com.

Centro 336

Celebrate Christmas Eve with an exquisite dining experience at Centro 336. Enjoy a specially curated menu featuring a variety of elegant starters, entrées, and festive flavors in a warm, inviting atmosphere. Make lasting holiday memories with your loved ones while indulging in expertly crafted dishes and exceptional service. Reservations are highly recommended for this unforgettable evening. Click here for menu.

Where: 336 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, (631) 594-5744, 336hamptonbays.com

Mirabelle at Three Village Inn 

Celebrate the magic of the season with unforgettable holiday events at Mirabelle. From festive fun with Santa to elegant holiday dining, there’s something special for everyone. Join us for a Magical Buffet with Santa & Friends on December 14th, 15th, 21st, and 22nd from 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM and create lasting holiday memories. Then, on Christmas Eve, enjoy a spectacular 3-course prix fixe menu in an elegant setting, with reservations available from 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM. Make this holiday season truly memorable at Mirabelle! Call or Reserve Online! (631) 751-0555.

Where: 150 Main Street, Stony Brook.

Sandbar 

Celebrate Christmas Eve at Sandbar on Tuesday, December 24th from 4:00 PM – 8:00 PM. Join us for a festive evening of exceptional dining. Enjoy a beautifully curated menu in the warm ambiance of our restaurant.  Reservations are highly recommended—secure your table today for an unforgettable holiday experience. Celebrate the season with sophistication and flavor! Call or Reserve Your Table Online! (631) 498-6188.

Where: 55 Main Street, Cold Spring Harbor, Book here!

Other restaurants open on Christmas Eve:

• Inn at Fox Hollow – 7755 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury
• Bistro 72 – 1830 West Main Street, Riverhead
• Ferryman’s Grille at Danford’s -25 East Broadway, Port Jefferson
• Robkes – 427 Fort Salonga Road, Northport
• Il Toscano Seafood & Steak – 6330 Jericho Turnpike, Commack
• Bella Vie -240 W Main St, Bay Shore
• Trento Italian Steakhouse – 1058 Broadhollow Rd, Farmingdale

Breakfast & Brunch With Santa

Village Idiot Pub

Santa makes his first stop at the VIP on Saturday, 12/14! Make your reservations now for Breakfast with Santa! Four locations across Suffolk County. Call for reservations! (631) 289-8471.

• Village Idiot Pub PATCHOGUE – Saturday, 12/14 at 9AM
• Village Idiot Pub OAKDALE – Sunday, 12/15 at 9AM
• Village Idiot Pub LAKE GROVE – Sunday, 12/15 at 10AM
• Village Idiot Pub RIVERHEAD – Sunday, 12/22 at 11AM

Library Cafe

Celebrate the Christmas season with the two best things: Santa and Brunch! Join us on Sunday, December 22nd, with time slots at 10:00 AM, 12:00 PM, or 2:00 PM, for the ultimate family experience. Enjoy mini bagels and muffins at the table, along with festive holiday cocktails to get you in the spirit. Then, savor our delightful brunch buffet selections crafted to make your holiday truly special! Call to Reserve! (516) 752-7678.

When: Sunday, December 22nd

Where: 274 Main Street Farmingdale.

More spots where you can have brunch with Santa:

• Garden Grill – Sun, Dec 15 & Sun, Dec 22, 10am-2:30pm, Smithtown, 64 N Country Rd, Smithtown
• Desmond’s – Sun, Dec 15 from 10am – 3pm  Shoppes at East Wind,  5720 NY-25A, Wading River
• Milleridge Inn – Sun, Dec 22, 585 North Broadway, Jericho
• Coral House – Sat, Dec 14; Sun, Dec 15; Sat, Dec 21; Sun Dec 22, 70 Milburn Ave, Baldwin
• The Royal Palm – Sun, Dec 22, 2143 Boundary Ave, Farmingdale
• Cowfish – Sat, Dec 21, 258 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
• Lily Flanagan’s -Sat, Dec 21, 345 Deer Pk Ave., Babylon
• The Mansion at Glen Cove – Dec. 7-22 (except Dec. 14), Saturdays and Sundays, 9 am – 1 pm, 200 Dosoris Lane, Glen Cove
• The American Airpower Museum – Sat, Dec 14, 9-10 am, 10-11 am & 11 am-12pm, 1230 New Hwy., Farmingdale
• Rhum – Sat, Dec. 14, 10:30 am – 3:30 pm, 13 E Main St., Patchogue
• The View – Sun, Dec 22nd, 11am-12:30pm, 3 Consuelo Place, Oakdale, www.viewoakdale.com.
• American Beauty Restaurant – Sat, Dec 14 10am-Noon & 1-3pm, Sat Dec 21, brunch with The Grinch, 1026 Park Blvd, Massapequa Park

Holiday Catering

Yaphank Deli

Make Christmas morning stress-free and delicious with Yaphank Deli’s pre-made breakfast casseroles, ready to heat and serve! Choose from French Toast Casserole, Ham & Cheese Croissant Casserole, Breakfast Casserole, or Hashbrown Casserole with Sausage and Cheese, all served in half trays for $28.99 each. Add on sides like bacon and sausage or home fries for $35.99 each. Orders must be placed by 12/21 and picked up on Christmas Eve. Call (631) 775-6464 to order!

Where: 908 E Main St, Yaphank, NY | (631) 775-6464

Other spots for holiday catering:

• Nomiya Station – 630 Old Country Road, Garden City (Roosevelt Field Mall), www.nomiyastation.com
• Uncle Giuseppe’s – Multiple locations across Long Island
• Lombardi’s Market – 1055 Main St, Holbrook
• Pasta Pasta – 234 East Main Street, Port Jefferson
• Zorn’s – 4321 Hempstead Turnpike, Bethpage
• American Beauty Restaurant – 1026 Park Blvd, Massapequa Park

Holiday Cakes & Cookies

Yaphank Deli

Pies available! APPLE ($26), APPLE CRUMB ($26), BLUEBERRY ($26), CARAMEL APPLE WALNUT ($28), CHOCOLATE CREAM ($26), KEY LIME ($32), LEMON MERINGUE ($21), PECAN CHOCOLATE CHIP ($26), SOUTHERN BOURBON PECAN ($25), STRAWBERRY RHUBARB ($25), TOASTED COCONUT CUSTARD ($25), PUMPKIN ($25), PUMPKIN MERINGUE ($28). Call (631) 775-6464 to order!

Where: 908 E Main St, Yaphank, NY | (631) 775-6464

A Pound & A Half Cookies and Cupcakes

order a holiday themed cookie, brownie, brookie or crownie for $30. Brownie platter, 24 for $20. Place your Christmas orders by 12/17. Text (516) 351-4901 to order!

Blog